17 Comments

I think this is what “responsive teaching” is supposed to mean. And sort of does? It just is ill-defined because the set of things the teacher responds to and the set of responses is so open to interpretation. But narrow and specify both sets and we’d have something meaningful.

Expand full comment

I totally see how this is useful, especially for groups that struggle at self-management, but I wonder how to build on this so that over time everyone, even groups that start pretty low on the self-management scale, can get better at working independently and in looser, less controlled environments. My worry is that students would become completely reliant on teachers for controlling and managing their learning environments if they only experienced this style of teaching. What do you think?

Expand full comment

Some quick thoughts on this good question:

1. Sometimes it's just a matter of age.

2. As long as you don't institutionalize this form of teaching ("The Pershan Academy for Fussy Instruction") then the kids will let you know when they're ready.

3. When I'm teaching like this, and I notice that independent work is going well, I'll often let it go for longer. Why not? So partly the answer is to be open to being surprised by students and following their lead -- but knowing how to take the reins back when needed.

Expand full comment

Another potential descriptor is "controlling". What you've outlined is a model of teaching in which the teacher controls exactly what every single student is supposed to be doing at every moment. It's less a model of learning and more a model of classroom management. Or just... manage your classroom so well that everyone is always on task and they'll probably learn a lot regardless of how you teach.

Expand full comment

Absolutely, this is definitely controlling. (That, undoubtedly, is part of what makes it somewhat annoying.) But when the going gets rough, the teacher should get controlling. In my experience the alternative is far more disappointing to everyone.

Expand full comment

Also controlling has a different meaning when it comes to teacher behaviour research. It means controllling use of rewards and punishments, controlling language. Asking students to do more and faster learning tasks isn’t controlling. It’s just brisk pace, which is something Archer promotes. I like switching modes because it snaps students out of whatever learning or behavioural rut they’re in.

Expand full comment

Yeah, I'm not saying if it's good or bad. It's probably mostly good. When I observe my kids' elementary school teachers, i'm always taken aback by how tightly everything is controlled. Totally unlike how I run my classroom, but they're probably doing a better job!

Expand full comment

I wouldn't say it's universally good/bad. I'd say it's a style of teaching that I use when I need it.

Expand full comment

This description of fussy teaching is very much in line with Rosenshine’s principles which are applicable across all ages, levels of development and subject matter.

Expand full comment

I’m curious if you’ve ever taught SRA Direct Instruction curriculum. Because engagement is very, very high.

Expand full comment

.. maybe high and warm demand?

Expand full comment

I'll bite.

This is counterdistracting teaching. Or perhaps, teaching to counterdistract.

I'm also open to The Controlling Sage on the M'fing Stage.

We shall keep worshipping.

But seriously, I like counterdistracting.

Expand full comment

Demand Attention Pedagogy. "DAP them up."

That would sell.

Expand full comment

This is how I teach Alg1. A funny thing about this approach is that your curricular materials become really hard to share with another teacher.

If someone asks what I’m doing to introduce slope today, it’s a sequence of 6 mini activities, not one big packet.

Expand full comment

I like this approach for a smaller intervention groups where all students are more or less in the same place and where students aren’t accustomed to being engaged in intellectual work for an entire class (hence need for intervention).

Expand full comment

You’ve got something here.

Expand full comment

I’m the fussiest! Every kid, every question! 🙋‍♀️

Expand full comment